Effective doesn’t always mean successful
This is probably the idea I feel most strongly about.
It’s understandable why effectiveness conversations often become pass-or-fail conversations. Targets matter. We’re all accountable for delivering them. Clients, stakeholders and boards quite rightly want to know whether objectives were achieved.
The risk is that we sometimes stop the conversation there.
Hit the target? Success.
Miss the target? Failure.
Move on.
But some of the most valuable campaigns I’ve worked on didn’t fully achieve their objectives.
They still taught us something important. They helped us understand audiences better. They highlighted barriers we hadn’t considered. They gave us evidence we could use to improve the next campaign. And they still delivered value.
Two of the three campaigns I discussed during the session didn’t fully achieve their objectives. Yet I would still argue they were effective.
Why?
Because effectiveness isn’t really about proving success.
It’s about reducing uncertainty.
It’s about understanding what happened, why it happened and what we should do next.
The reusable cup campaign didn’t hit its target, but it still delivered significant behaviour change. More importantly, the evaluation gave us useful clues about where the remaining barriers existed and how those barriers might be addressed in future.
That’s valuable.
That’s useful.
And that’s exactly what good evaluation should do.
The simplest definition of effectiveness I’ve found is this:
Did we win? Fantastic. Let’s understand why and do more of it.
Did we learn? Fantastic. Let’s understand why and improve next time.
The real failure isn’t missing a target.
The real failure is finishing a campaign and having no idea what happened.